top of page

Our Team

Katie Vollmer

Katie Vollmer

Business Development Director, Compliance Officer, & Notary Public

Diana Surface

Diana Surface

Licensed Agent

Hannah Schuck

Hannah Schuck

Financial Products Coordinator & Notary Public

Joan Johnston

Joan Johnston

Licensed Agent

Wilma Hicks

Wilma Hicks

Licensed Agent & Notary Public

Caleb Sumner

Caleb Sumner

Agency Owner, Principal, Licensed Agent

Michael Bauer

Michael Bauer

Licensed Agent

Scott Venable

Scott Venable

Licensed Agent

Matthew Sumner

Matthew Sumner

Operations Support Specialist

Luke Rehmer

Luke Rehmer

Licensed Agent

Laramey Johnson

Laramey Johnson

Licensed Agent

Elaine Day

Elaine Day

Client Engagement Specialist

Casey Sumner

Casey Sumner

Chief Operating Officer

Brenda Bottcher

Brenda Bottcher

Licensed Agent

Kim Tagtmeyer

Kim Tagtmeyer

Operations Support Specialist

Madeline Sumner

Madeline Sumner

Operations Support Specialist

Drew Lusk

Drew Lusk

Licensed Agent

Jon Hill

Jon Hill

Licensed Agent

Debbie Cormican

Debbie Cormican

Property & Casualty Coordinator

Sarah Albin

Sarah Albin

Health & Medicare Products Coordinator & Notary Public

Emily Burgoon

Emily Burgoon

Digital Consultant

Office Information

Main Office:

2300 W. Broadway Blvd., Sedalia, MO 65301

Satellite Office:

120 S. Maple St., Cole Camp, MO 65325

fax blue_edited.png
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
maia-logo.png

Insure your place in heaven by trusting in Christ today

I understand a sales agent may contact me by telephone, email or mail to discuss Medicare Advantage Plans, Prescription Drug Plans, Medicare Supplement Plans, and other insurance products. We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent 14 organizations which offer 149 products in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-Medicare, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options.

© 2025 Sumner Insurance Services. All Rights Reserved.  

bottom of page